Health, Mortality, and Eternity
At the start of our men’s meeting, we have a scrolling list of parishioners who are sick. The list seems endless—over sixty names, each one dealing with serious illness.
Watching this week after week, I couldn’t help but compare it to what I’ve been learning about diet and health. Doctors who promote the carnivore diet claim it prevents most of the diseases we see all around us—heart disease, diabetes, cancer, dementia, thyroid problems, even tooth decay. In theory, if people ate differently, they might never face decades of medical decline. They’d stay healthy until the end of their lives, only needing a hospital if they had an accident or injury.
It sounds almost too good to be true. But here’s the question that troubles me: if disease can bring people to a halt—forcing them to face mortality and the eternal destiny of their souls—then maybe sickness is not only a curse but also a strange kind of blessing. How many have repented, turned to God, or reconsidered their lives only because sickness knocked them down? If they had stayed strong and healthy their whole lives, maybe they never would have.
So I hesitate. Should I even recommend a diet that might take away this painful but powerful path to conversion? Is that a twisted thought?
A Christian Response
It’s not twisted—it’s an old and serious question. Christians have always wrestled with the mystery of suffering.
1. Suffering can open hearts.
St. Paul himself spoke of a “thorn in the flesh” that kept him humble and close to Christ (2 Corinthians 12:7–10). Many saints saw their illnesses as a way of uniting themselves to Jesus’ cross. There’s no doubt: suffering can wake people up to God.
2. But health is also a gift.
Scripture calls the body the “temple of the Holy Spirit” (1 Corinthians 6:19). Caring for our health isn’t vanity—it’s stewardship. A sound body allows us to serve others, to work, to pray, to love with strength. Preventing disease isn’t selfish; it’s a way of honoring God.
3. God does not need disease to save us.
While illness may bring some to repentance, it’s not the only path. God works through conscience, grace, community, and the sacraments. A healthy man who uses his strength for good can be just as close—or closer—to God as a sick man who cries out in weakness.
4. Our task is balance.
We should encourage health, but not worship it. We should be grateful for medicine and nutrition, but not forget that even the healthiest life ends in death. Whether sick or strong, the real question is whether we are preparing for eternity.
The Takeaway
Yes, disease can be a strange blessing when it drives someone back to God. But it’s not a blessing in itself—it’s a hardship God can redeem. Health, too, is a blessing, when we use it in service and gratitude.
So perhaps the answer is not to hesitate about encouraging better health, but to remind ourselves and others: even if we escape disease, we will not escape death. Eternity still awaits. The real question is not only how long we live, but how ready we are to meet the Lord.
Reflection Question:
Do I see my health—or my sickness—as a way to serve God and prepare for eternity?
Developed with assistance from ChatGPT-5