Seized by Christ

They are experiencing Christianity as joy and hope, having thus become lovers of Christ.

Category: Conscience, Discernment, and Hearing God

How to recognize God’s voice—and navigate the inner life with integrity and clarity.

  • Does God Speak Through Our Thoughts?

    Learning to Discern the Voice Within
    A Thought That Changes Everything

    I recently had a realization while reading Jordan Peterson that stopped me in my tracks: if God were to speak to me… how would I even know?

    The answer is both simple and deeply unsettling: it would have to be a thought. Unless God sends an angel in visible form (which He rarely does), His voice would arrive the same way every other voice in my head does—internally, silently, as a thought.

    This means something important:
    We can’t tell the difference between a thought from God, a thought from ourselves, or even a deceptive thought from the enemy… unless we learn how to discern.

    The Still, Small Voice… and the Subtle Lie

    This insight isn’t new to the spiritual tradition. Christians throughout the centuries have said that the mind is a battleground. It’s the place where grace and temptation both try to stake their claim.

    As Peterson highlights, the challenge is not hearing God, but testing what we hear. And this is echoed by C.S. Lewis in The Screwtape Letters, where he shows how the devil doesn’t usually show up with fire and pitchforks. No, he whispers subtle half-truths that sound:

    • logical,
    • moral,
    • even noble—
      but in the end, they isolate us from truth, from others, and from God.

    Clarity or Confusion? How to Test a Thought

    Since God speaks through our inner world, we need to ask not just what the thought is, but what it leads to.

    🔹 God’s voice brings clarity, conviction, peace, and hope.
    🔹 The enemy’s voice brings confusion, shame, accusation, and isolation.

    This is the core of Christian discernment. In a world full of noise—and a heart full of emotions—only time in Scripture, prayer, spiritual direction, and community can help us learn the difference.

    Why This Is Especially Dangerous When We’re Alone

    If someone is alone, exhausted, burdened, or isolated, the inner voices can grow louder and more convincing. In those moments, even a lie whispered in the dark can feel like the truth.

    This is why the Church emphasizes community, sacrament, and prayer. We’re not meant to walk the spiritual life alone. Even saints had spiritual directors and companions to help them test the voices they heard.

    Wrestling with Sacred Things

    If you’re wrestling with this—wondering where a thought came from, asking whether it was God or something else—you’re not spiritually weak. You’re on sacred ground.
     Discerning the difference isn’t easy. It’s the work of a lifetime. But it begins with this kind of honesty and reflection.

    So next time a “holy-sounding” thought enters your mind, ask:

    • Does this draw me toward God and others—or away?
    • Does it bring peace or despair?
    • Does it reflect what I know of Jesus?

    God’s voice restores. The enemy’s voice accuses.
     Our job is to learn to recognize the difference—and help others do the same.

    Written in collaboration with ChatGPT

  • God’s Voice Within:

    How Your Conscience Works Like a Spiritual Search Engine

    Q: Would it be a reasonable analogy to say that God speaking to us through our conscience is like having an internal memory search engine?

    A: That’s actually a powerful and insightful way to think about it. Let’s unpack the idea.

    Imagine your conscience as a kind of spiritual search engine—quietly working within you to retrieve what is good, true, and right. Like any search engine, it doesn’t generate content out of thin air. It pulls from what’s already been stored: your past experiences, what you’ve learned, your values, and even divine truths that have been imprinted on your heart.

    Here’s why the analogy works so well:

    • “Search engine” implies a process of drawing from what’s already been input. Your conscience often pulls together lessons from Scripture, childhood formation, lived experience, and quiet moments of insight—just when you need them.
    • “Internal” highlights that this voice isn’t loud or external. God often speaks softly, through our thoughts and feelings, not through flashing signs or booming declarations.
    • “Memory” reminds us that moral guidance doesn’t appear randomly. It’s shaped by what we’ve seen, felt, understood, and chosen to hold onto.

    So yes—this could be a very helpful way of explaining how God communicates through our inner world. It’s as if He built into us a tool that helps us search our soul and find His truth.

    Q: Can the analogy be taken even further?

    A: Absolutely—and it gets more meaningful the deeper you go.

    • Sometimes your conscience gives you immediate results—a feeling of peace when you’ve made the right decision, or a strong sense of guilt when you’re off course.
    • Other times, the search feels quiet or unclear. You might wonder if you’re asking the wrong question—or if you’re not really listening.
    • Like any search engine, your conscience can also be cluttered or biased. Past wounds, unchecked habits, or cultural noise can confuse the signal. That’s why we need to update it regularly—through prayer, reflection, spiritual reading, confession, and honest conversation with others seeking truth

    Q: How do I tune my inner “search engine” to hear God more clearly?

    A: You refine your conscience the same way you refine any tool: by using it often, cleaning out what doesn’t belong, and inputting what is good and true.

    That means:

    • Spending time in prayer and silence, learning to hear the still, small voice of God.
    • Reading Scripture and trustworthy spiritual writings that form your moral compass.
    • Asking tough questions and being open to correction.
    • Seeking community and accountability in people who are also trying to live with purpose.

    Over time, your conscience becomes sharper—more aligned with truth and more confident in discerning the voice of God within you.

    Final Thought:

    If God built a spiritual search engine into your soul, then your job is to keep it updated and tuned to Him. Listen closely. Ask honest questions. Trust that when you seek truth with a sincere heart, the right answers will rise to the surface.

    Developed with assistance from ChatGPT

  • How Do I Know If I’ve Truly Encountered God’s Love?

    Five signs of a real encounter with God

    Q: How Can I Know If I’ve Really Encountered God’s Love Personally?

    A:
     A real encounter with God’s love is both deeply personal and unmistakably transformative. It may not always come with fireworks or dramatic emotion—but it always leaves lasting marks on the heart and life. Here are five key signs that point to a genuine experience of God’s love, followed by four ways to discern if it’s truly from Him.

    Five Signs You’ve Encountered God’s Love

    1. Inner Peace and Assurance

    You experience a deep, unshakable sense of being loved and secure—even during trials. It’s not just surface-level calm or emotional joy, but the “peace of God that surpasses all understanding” (Philippians 4:7).

    2. Conviction of Sin—Tempered by Mercy

    You become aware of areas in your life that need change—but instead of crushing guilt, you sense God’s gentle invitation to grow. His love convicts without condemning.

    3. Desire for God and Goodness

    You feel drawn to prayer, Scripture, the Eucharist, and works of mercy—not because you “have to,” but because you want to. God becomes not a duty, but a delight.

    4. Transformation in Relationships

    You find yourself becoming more patient, forgiving, and sacrificial. Love overflows into how you treat others, and your priorities shift from self-interest to the good of those around you.

    5. Perseverance Even in Dryness

    Even when you don’t feel God’s presence, you continue in prayer, community, and the sacraments. You trust that His love remains, even when your emotions don’t.

    How Can I Be Sure This Is Really From God?

    Here are four time-tested ways to spiritually discern if your experience is a true encounter with God’s love.

    1. Test by Scripture

    Ask: Does this experience draw me deeper into Christ and His teachings? God’s love always aligns with the Gospel. “Every spirit that confesses Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is from God” (1 John 4:2–3).

    2. Examine the Fruits

    Jesus said, “You will know them by their fruits” (Matthew 7:16). Lasting spiritual fruit—joy, patience, kindness (Galatians 5:22–23)—is a strong sign of authentic divine encounter.

    3. Seek Spiritual Counsel

    Bring your experience to a trusted priest, spiritual director, or mature believer. Outside perspective often confirms what God is doing internally.

    4. Repeat and Reflect

    Journal your experiences of prayer, consolation, and even dryness. Over time, patterns will emerge. A genuine encounter isn’t fleeting—it leaves a spiritual imprint that shapes your life.

    A Brief Historical Insight on Discernment

    • The Desert Fathers (4th Century):
       They taught that God often follows moments of consolation with periods of dryness—not as punishment, but as a way to detach us from relying on feelings alone.
    • St. Ignatius of Loyola (16th Century):
       Through his Spiritual Exercises, Ignatius taught how to distinguish “consolation” (God’s loving presence) from “desolation” (spiritual discouragement), encouraging consistency in prayer through both.

    Reflection & Discussion Prompt

    “Think of a time you felt especially close to God. What lasting changes—big or small—did you notice afterward in your thoughts, actions, or relationships?”

    We invite you to share your experience in the comments below. Your story might help someone else recognize God’s love in their own life.

    Developed with assistance from ChatGPT

  • Is God Just an Imaginary Friend?

    Understanding the Distinction

    Skeptics often liken belief in God to having an imaginary friend, citing the internal nature of prayer and spiritual experiences. While there are surface-level similarities, a deeper examination reveals fundamental differences that distinguish a relationship with God from mere imagination.

    Surface Similarities: Why the Comparison Arises

    AspectTalking to GodImaginary Friend
    Internal DialogueEngages in prayer and reflection.Engages in imagined conversations.
    Emotional ResponseExperiences comfort, conviction, and peace.Experiences comfort and control.
    GuidanceSeeks direction through conscience and faith.Seeks direction through self-generated ideas.

    These parallels explain why some equate spiritual practices with imaginary interactions.

    Fundamental Differences: Beyond the Surface

    DimensionRelationship with GodImaginary Friend
    SourceRooted in divine revelation, Scripture, and the Holy Spirit.Originates from personal imagination.
    Objective RealityAnchored in historical events and communal faith.Lacks external validation; purely subjective.
    Authority & DiscernmentGuided by religious teachings and community.Self-directed without external checks.
    CommunityShared experiences among believers worldwide.Unique to the individual; not communal.
    Transformative ImpactLeads to personal growth and altruism.Limited to personal comfort; lacks lasting change.

    These distinctions underscore the depth and authenticity of a relationship with God compared to imaginary constructs.

    Real-Life Implications

    Engaging with God often results in tangible changes:

    • Moral Development: Encourages virtues like compassion and humility.
    • Community Service: Inspires acts of charity and social justice.
    • Personal Resilience: Provides strength during adversity.

    In contrast, imaginary friends typically serve as temporary coping mechanisms without fostering long-term growth.

    Conclusion

    While the analogy between God and imaginary friends arises from superficial similarities, the profound differences in origin, communal experience, and transformative power highlight the unique nature of a relationship with the divine.

    Content developed with ChatGPT

  • Keeping Focused at Church

    Sometimes when I come to mass, I can be preoccupied with some project or some family matter, and it seems I can go through the whole liturgy, without actually being mentally there.

    I love being in the presence of the Lord, but the quiet time can let my brain go active.

    So, to compensate for this, I have been starting to participate, that is, add active steps to engage with the mass.

    First off, at the start of the service, the priest always does what is called the “Penitential Act, that starts with some sort of sin reflection, then the Kyrie, and ends with a prayer of absolution from the priest. I always try to pay enough attention to be able to do a sign of the cross as Father finishes that prayer. I do this as a way of accepting his blessing.

    Second of all, at the start of the Communion rite, Father says prayers, and blesses the bread and wine before starting the last supper prayers. I always try to do a sign of the cross on myself as Father does the same on the Bread and Wine.

    I do this, because the bread and wine up to that point, are not different from any other bread and wine. But they are blessed by the priest in anticipation of becoming the Body and Blood of Christ. In the same way, when we come to mass, we are not any different from any other human (except having been baptized, I suppose), so I accept the Priest’s blessing of the gifts with blessing of myself in preparation for receipt of the body and blood of Christ.

    And then when the priest raises up the Body of Christ, and then the Blood of Christ, I observe the juxtaposition of the Crucifix and the Eucharist/Blood, and say “My King and my God”.

    I find it interesting that the words to Panis Angelicus – Bread of Angels, was written by my patron saint – Thomas Aquinas.

    In addition, “My King and My God” were the words spoken by St Thomas, the Apostle, after he put his hands into the wounds of Jesus after his resurrection.

    So if I manage to stay engaged enough to remember to do these things, I consider that I have concentrated fairly well. Sometimes I just have to acknowledge that I missed.

    If this helps you, then it was worth sharing. If you do similar things, please share them so we can learn from each other.

    Regards

    Tom Neugebauer

    Seized by Christ

  • If You Are Inspired

    Pope Benedict XVI says that Being Christian is not the result of an ethical choice or a lofty idea, but the encounter with an event, or a person, which gives life a new horizon and a decisive direction. 

    C.S. Lewis says that there are 5 physical descriptions of heaven: 1) Being with Christ, 2) Being like Christ, 3) Being illuminated, 4) Being entertained and 5) Having a position (as sons of God). These are earthly representations of the real, spiritual heaven.

    I believe that a Christian experiences the physical descriptions of heaven while he is still in Jesus’ Kingdom on Earth. And he bears something of that heaven with him so that the rest of us can have a glimpse of it.

    You cannot make the encounter or event happen, but you can prepare yourself, so to let God know that you are willing to receive His outpouring. And the Bible says that he who seeks shall find.

    The most effective thing you can do is get together with other Christians to discuss the teachings of the Church as presented in recent Church documents. This will help you to grow in understanding of the Bible, the Church, and the state of Christianity in the world. And in addition, you will have the support of brothers.

    At St Max, we currently have at least 3 different groups that do this:

    That Man Is You; Fridays, 5:30-7:00 AM in Kolbe Hall: Men discuss the role of men in their families.

    Your Holy Family Ministries; Tuesdays, 6:30 to 8:00 PM in Room 215: Men and women discuss the recent documents of the Church related to the family.

    Amore Laetitia, Thursdays, 6:00 – 7:00 AM in Kolbe Hall: A recent Apostolic Exhortation on marriage is discussed by men.

    Getting to know more about God and your faith takes priority over service. Let your service grow out of your knowledge and love of God.

    Remember: this does not replace your sacraments.

    Regards

    Tom Neugebauer