From possibility to discernment — a practical guide for those considering priesthood or consecrated life

Introduction: From Coin Toss to Questions

In our last reflection, we looked at priestly vocations through the lens of statistics. With one diocesan priest for every 3,000 Catholic men, vocations today can seem almost miraculous — like flipping twelve coins and getting heads every time.

But what if we replaced those twelve coins with seven questions? Questions that, if answered honestly and faithfully, could help a man discern whether he is called to a consecrated vocation. This approach moves from mere probability to spiritual discernment, from abstract numbers to personal reflection.

---

The Seven Questions from Catholic to Consecrated Vocation

1. Grace

• Are you being honest with yourself?
• Are you committed to putting God’s will first?
• Do you trust God’s providence for your future?
• Are you aware that those who give all for Christ will bear much fruit and be rewarded with joy and peace?

2. Vocation Fit

• Is there an organization or charism that complements your perceived vocation or interests?
• Could you see yourself participating fully and happily in that community?

3. Trust

• Are you comfortable that the group is faithful to Church teaching, transparent, and well-governed?
• Can you entrust your future obedience to this group with confidence?

4. Celibacy

• Are you willing to accept celibacy as a sign of trust and commitment to God?
• Do you recognize the benefits of consecrated celibacy over marriage within this vocation?
• Could your vocation be fulfilled outside a celibate life?
• Would marriage prevent you from living this vocation fully?
• Do you believe that, by God’s grace, a person can sacrifice personal benefit for God’s plan?

5. Service

• Do you understand the importance of the presence of consecrated religious for the well-being of families, the Church, and the salvation of souls?
• Is the vocational need significant enough to justify the sacrifices required?
• Are you aware that Christ is present in each person you will serve?

6. Compatibility

• Will consecration to this group allow you to achieve your broader vocation?
• Will the group allow flexibility as your vocation evolves with your faith?

7. Timing

• Do you believe God is calling you now, or might the call come at a later time?

---

Reflection

Most of the stumbling blocks I’ve observed are not about rules or regulations, but trust in God. Many men hesitate to surrender personal freedom — especially sexuality — because they do not truly know God or experience His providence in their lives.

In reality, this is the same reason many do not fully live as Christians in the first place. Cardinal Ratzinger phrased it poignantly:

Have you experienced an event or person which gives life a new horizon, and a decisive direction? Do you experience it as joy and hope? Are you inwardly seized by Christianity, and have you become a lover of Christ?

Vocations grow from a foundation of encounter with Christ. Without that, no set of questions, rules, or statistics can bear fruit.

---

Conclusion

By replacing the coin tosses with these seven questions, we can move from seeing vocations as statistical miracles to seeing them as discernible possibilities. But the first and most important step is always the same: knowing Christ and trusting Him with your life.

Developed with assistance from ChatGPT-5